NFL Report:  The Commissioner's View  --  Spring 1999
DRAFT ANOTHER NFL INNOVATION

They gathered in a meeting room of the Ritz Carlton Hotel in Philadelphia, the men who ran the National Football League’s nine clubs. The date was February 8, 1936. The occasion was the NFL’s inaugural college player draft, the first of its sort by any professional sports league.

The event bore little resemblance to the current NFL draft with team “war rooms” spread from coast to coast, sophisticated year-round scouting operations, tremendous fan interest, and massive media coverage such as ESPN’s wall-to-wall national telecast. For that first draft, a list of about 90 players was posted on a blackboard in the hotel meeting room. The scant information on players that existed at the time consisted mainly of lists of All-America teams selected at the end of the college season.

The attendees that day included many of the league’s pioneers: George Halas, Art Rooney, Tim Mara, Bert Bell, George Preston Marshall, and Curly Lambeau. There was good-natured joking and even some music, with Cardinals coach Jimmy Conzelman playing the piano and George Preston Marshall doing the singing during lulls in the day. It had some of the atmosphere of a party.

The NFL is credited with developing the essential structure of the modern sports league. And no idea was more important to the success of the NFL, and ultimately to the growth of professional sports, than the draft. It created competitive balance, giving all teams a chance to win and expanding interest in the league. Pro Football Hall of Fame coach and owner Paul Brown once called the draft “the lifeblood of the business.”

Who came up with the idea, you ask?

The answer is deBenneville Bell, better known as Bert Bell. From a prominent Philadelphia family (which owned the city’s Ritz Carlton Hotel), Bert Bell loved football, which he played at the University of Pennsylvania. In 1933, he and a partner were awarded the defunct Frankford Yellow Jackets, which they immediately moved to Philadelphia and renamed the Eagles.

The problem for Bell’s new franchise was that it was unable to attract first-rate playing talent in the NFL’s free-for-all system of the time. The league was ruled on and off the field in those days by the Chicago Bears, New York Giants, and Green Bay Packers. Realizing that the only way for lesser teams to improve was to have first shot at incoming players, Bell proposed at a league meeting in May of 1935 his idea for an annual draft of college players, much as the military drafted individuals into specific branches of the service.

The NFL’s visionary leaders supported the plan, to the surprise of some, because they understood how it would spread interest in the game. Current Giants co-owner Wellington Mara remembers his father Tim saying, “This is something we should do because we’re not going to be any stronger than our so-called weaker clubs.”

With the league’s worst record the previous year, Bell’s Eagles had the first pick in the first draft. The choice was 1935 Heisman Trophy winner Jay Berwanger from the University of Chicago. Bell promptly traded Berwanger to the Bears for veteran tackle Art Buss.

As it turned out, Berwanger never played pro football and Bell failed to sign any of his eight remaining draft picks that year. But the NFL and its draft grew into an enormous success, as did Bert Bell. He went on to become an outstanding NFL commissioner from 1946 until his death in 1959. Appropriately, original-thinker Bell was an original inductee into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1963.

(For an entertaining history of the draft, read Sleepers, Busts, & Franchise Makers by Cliff Christl and Don Langenkamp.)